Residence Based Taxation Act: A Potential Game-Changer for US Expat Taxation

A Potential Game-Changer for US Expat Taxation

A significant development for US citizens living abroad emerged on December 18, 2024, as Congressman LaHood of Illinois introduced the "Residence Based Taxation for Americans Abroad Act." This legislation could fundamentally change how US citizens living overseas are taxed, potentially offering relief from the current citizenship-based taxation system.

Why This Matters Now

While previous attempts at reforming expat taxation have been made, including the 2018 Tax Fairness for Americans Abroad Act, several factors make this current proposal particularly noteworthy:

• Growing expat population (estimated between 5.5-9 million US citizens living abroad)
• Increased public discourse around expat taxation challenges, including recent campaign attention
• Rising court challenges to current expat filing requirements
• Bipartisan recognition of the need for reform

Key Problems Being Addressed

The current system presents several challenges:

• Excessive complexity and high tax preparation costs
• Unclear guidance on foreign pensions and trusts
• Investment restrictions due to PFIC rules on foreign mutual funds
• Banking difficulties due to FATCA regulations
• Operational burden of maintaining US tax compliance while living abroad
• Double taxation in specific scenarios (e.g., net investment income tax, exit taxes)

Key Provisions of the Proposed Legislation

Elective Non-Resident Status

The cornerstone of this legislation is the introduction of an elective non-resident status for qualifying US citizens abroad. This status would:

• Allow US citizens to be taxed as non-residents while maintaining citizenship
• Require meeting the "bona fide residence test" (similar to current Section 911 criteria)
• Limit US taxation to US-sourced income only
• Eliminate complex reporting requirements such as controlled foreign corporations, foreign trusts, and PFICs

Qualification Requirements

To elect non-resident status, expatriates must:

1. Demonstrate bona fide residence in a foreign country for an entire calendar year
2. Complete a five-year certification period showing accurate and complete tax return filing
3. Pay a user fee (similar to the current citizenship renunciation fee)

The Departure Tax Component

Similar to current exit tax provisions, the legislation includes a departure tax with specific considerations:

• Applies to individuals with net worth exceeding $2 million
• Includes exemptions for:
  • Long-term expats (defined as 3+ years of foreign residence)
  • "Accidental Americans" (those who acquired citizenship through birth but have limited US ties)
  • Other qualified long-term foreign residents

Practical Implications

Investment Considerations

The proposed changes could create both opportunities and challenges:

1. Estate Tax Planning: Non-resident status would reduce the estate tax exemption from current levels (approximately $13 million) to $60,000 for US-sited assets
2. Investment Opportunities: Potential access to favorable non-resident investment treatment in US markets
3. Business Structure Optimization: Possibilities for tax-efficient operation of US-connected businesses from abroad

Ongoing Obligations

Even under non-resident status, certain US obligations would remain:

• FBAR filing requirements would continue
• US-sourced income would still be subject to US taxation
• Compliance with departure tax provisions where applicable

Looking Forward

While this legislation represents a potentially transformative change for US expats, several factors warrant consideration:

1. The bill must pass both houses of Congress and likely will undergo significant modifications
2. Implementation details, particularly around the departure tax and certification requirements, need refinement
3. The full cost implications for the US tax base require further analysis

Potential Alternative Outcomes

Even if comprehensive residency-based taxation isn't enacted, possible reforms could include:

• Modified reporting requirements for smaller taxpayers
• Simplified foreign corporation reporting
• Reformed foreign trust reporting requirements
• Adjusted thresholds for various international information returns

It's worth noting that President-Elect Trump's more general claim of ending double taxation for expats is being supported by a 100 day campaign from The American Citizen Abroad (ACA). There's no telling what the final shape of this sort of reform might be, but it's exciting that it's finally being spoken about in a serious way instead of remaining a background issue.

Strategic Planning Considerations

While monitoring these developments, expats should:

1. Maintain accurate and complete tax records
2. Consider the timing of major financial decisions
3. Evaluate current investment and business structures
4. Consult with international tax professionals for personalized guidance

Conclusion

The Residence Based Taxation for Americans Abroad Act represents a significant step toward addressing the unique challenges faced by US expats. While the final form of any legislation may differ from the current proposal, the increased attention to expat tax reform suggests positive changes may be on the horizon.

If you have tax needs now then sign up for a free consultation, if you just want to stay informed and get the latest internal tax tips, sign up for our newsletter!